Ghostwriter Public House spent about five years at 49½ S. Main St. The next two restaurants in that building lasted about ten months between them. When Black Diamond Kitchen turned off its lights in early October, it didn't leave behind a "coming soon" sign. It left a lease agreement that, according to the company, will make room for additional office space for nearby tenants.
That change matters more than one more closing. For most of the past several years, the south block of Main Street had a sit-down dinner room with a bar in that space, and that kind of place is what keeps a downtown busy after 5 p.m. This holiday season, that space is empty, and no new restaurant has been announced. Johnstown's busiest downtown nights of the year, starting with trick-or-treat and ending with the Santa parade on December 5, will lean on a smaller group of businesses that are mostly a few doors up the street.
Two Years, Three Tenants, One Address
Here's how 49½ S. Main changed hands, based on NBC4's October 18 report and earlier coverage.
| Tenant | What it was | When it operated | How long |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ghostwriter Public House | Independent American restaurant | Closed February 2025 | About five years |
| Ray Ray's Hog Pit | Columbus-based barbecue chain | August to November 2025 | About three months |
| Black Diamond Kitchen | Steakhouse and taproom from Nelsonville-based Black Diamond Cos. | March to early October 2026 | About seven months |
The Columbus Dispatch covered Ghostwriter's permanent closing on February 27, 2025. The building then sat empty for roughly six months before the barbecue opened in August. After that, the gaps got shorter and so did the runs. Ray Ray's left in November, and Black Diamond opened about four months later.
Black Diamond Kitchen is relocating. Its website, as reported by NBC4, says it will reopen in November at 4418 Groveport Road in Obetz. 614NOW also reported the move on October 6. The company runs eight places across four brands in towns like Nelsonville, Circleville, Marietta and Waverly, and the Obetz location will serve steaks, burgers, seafood and pasta.
The Line in the Release That Matters for the Block
The restaurant was open about the reason. As NBC4 reported, it wrote in a Facebook post that has since been deleted:
"Our high-end steakhouse concept wasn't the right fit for this location. That's our responsibility. Growing a hospitality business means taking chances, learning from setbacks and moving forward with those lessons."
The detail that matters most for downtown came in a separate news release. NBC4 reported that Black Diamond and its Johnstown landlord reached a "mutually beneficial" agreement that will "accommodate the need for additional office space" for nearby tenants.
So far, no new restaurant has been announced for 49½ S. Main, and no final plan for the building has been made public. What is public is that the parties described the lease ending as serving office needs nearby. Office use and restaurants put different kinds of traffic on a block. One brings people at lunch on weekdays. The other brings people in the evening and on weekends.
Where Main Street Dinner and Coffee Stand This Fall
With 49½ S. Main empty, the downtown food that has shown public activity in 2026 sits within a short walk of Main Street Square.
- El Ray Mexican Restaurant, 65 S. Main St. The Johnstown Chamber says it opened in early 2026, which makes it the newest full-service restaurant on the street. The Chamber is holding its fall mixer there on Thursday, November 5. Some listings, including Explore Licking County, use the spelling El Rey.
- Leonard's Coffee Roasting Co., 32 S. Main St. It's a few doors north and has hosted Chamber events this year, including one on February 14, 2026.
- Hot Spot Coffeehouse, 94 W. Coshocton St. It's just off the square and held an Autumn Vendor Market on October 3.
- Mastodons Ice Cream Co., 60 S. Main St. 614NOW reported that it opened on May 14, 2025. Ice cream shops often change their hours in the cold months, so call ahead before a December stop.
Look at those addresses: 32, 60 and 65 S. Main. The empty building at 49½ is right in the middle. On December 5, people walking from the Opera House to El Ray will pass a storefront that held a bar and dining room for most of the past several years.
Trick-or-Treat Through the Tree Lighting
The busiest downtown nights from late October through early December all come from the Johnstown Chamber's event calendar.
| Date | Event | Time | Where |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thursday, October 29 | Villagewide trick-or-treat | 6 to 7:30 p.m. | Johnstown neighborhoods |
| Thursday, November 5 | Chamber fall mixer | Per Chamber listing | El Ray Mexican Restaurant, 65 S. Main St. |
| Friday, November 6 | Christmas on the Farm Ohio, with vendor marketplace | 4 to 7 p.m. | 12407 Drury Road |
| Saturday, November 7 | Christmas on the Farm Ohio | 10 a.m. to 3 p.m. | 12407 Drury Road |
| Saturday, December 5 | Johnstown CCL Cookie Walk | 9 a.m. to noon | Johnstown United Methodist Church, 159 S. Main St. |
| Saturday, December 5 | A Vintage Christmas, Light Up Main St. and Tree Lighting | 4 to 8 p.m. | Main Street |
| Saturday, December 5 | CCL Santa Parade | 5:30 to 6:30 p.m. | Downtown Johnstown |
Trick-or-treat falls on a Thursday this year and wraps up at 7:30 p.m., which leaves time for dinner downtown afterward. The November dates move the focus out to the farm on Drury Road for a weekend, and then everything comes back to Main Street.
How December 5 Runs, Block by Block
December 5 is the one day of the season when Main Street is busy from morning to night. Based on the Chamber's listings, it goes in this order:
- 9 a.m. to noon. The CCL Cookie Walk at Johnstown United Methodist Church, 159 S. Main St., on the south end of downtown.
- 4 p.m. A Vintage Christmas begins. The Chamber says downtown businesses will be open with activities and giveaways, plus horse and sleigh rides.
- 5:30 p.m. The CCL Santa Parade leaves Johnstown-Monroe High School and heads downtown.
- Around 6:30 p.m. The parade ends at the Johnstown Opera House on Main Street Square. The Opera House is the historic second-floor venue in the Town Hall building at 1 S. Main St.
- Until 8 p.m. Light Up Main St. and the tree lighting wrap up the evening.
The parade ends at 1 S. Main. From there, the lit-up businesses run south along the street: Leonard's at 32, Mastodons at 60, El Ray at 65 and the church at 159. The building at 49½ is right on that route. Last December, the barbecue had already closed and Black Diamond was still months from opening. This year the space is dark again, and the only public statement about its future concerns office space for nearby tenants.
On December 5, El Ray at 65 S. Main is the full-service restaurant on that stretch that opened in 2026. Leonard's at 32 S. Main and Hot Spot at 94 W. Coshocton are the coffee stops within a short walk of the square.
If you own a building or a home near downtown Johnstown and want to understand how a change like this one on Main Street can show up in what nearby properties are worth, Connie J Sadowski will walk you through it in person. Start with a free home valuation, or browse more Johnstown neighborhood coverage before the holiday season begins.